The Berean Expositor
Volume 22 - Page 199 of 214
Index | Zoom
proved. That which is proved is called the "conclusion", and the means whereby it is so
proved the "premises". Here is a simple example of a syllogism:--
All tyrants deserve death . . . . . Caesar was a tyrant . . . . . Therefore he deserved death.
We are not at the moment concerned with the morals of the matter before us, but with
the process of reasoning and its inevitable conclusions. There is no possible way of
avoiding the conclusion, "Therefore he deserved death", except by questioning and
disproving some feature of the premises. Either it is not true that all tyrants deserve
death, or it is true. Either it is true that Caesar was a tyrant, or it is not true. But if these
premises be conceded, then the conclusion is valid and unassailable.
One great value of the syllogism is the way in which it forces revision of the premises
or steps that lead to an erroneous conclusion. For example, there is nothing apparently
wrong with the following process of reasoning, yet the conclusion is so obviously untrue
that it compels a search for error in the premises that might otherwise have escaped us:--
White is a colour . . . . . Black is a colour . . . . . Therefore black is white.
When we realized that much that passes for scriptural doctrine will not stand the test
of the syllogism, we may look more kindly upon its application, and allow some place for
an explanation of its use.
Without allowing the subject to occupy undue space, we hope from time to time to
give a few notes upon the importance of correct reasoning and valid argument. This we
hope will prove to be of service in the elucidation of the truth of the Scriptures, and at the
same time provide some means of testing the doctrines propounded by teachers and
writers in these days of seducing spirits and doctrines of demons.
[NOTE.--As this series of articles is somewhat outside the bounds of actual
exposition and teaching, and deals with the raw material, and the processes,
rather than with the finished article, and as we wish our pages to be helpful to all
our readers, we have prepared six articles only under this heading, and shall be
guided as to their continuance by the correspondence we receive. If you desire
their continuance, please say so on a postcard addressed to the Editor.]