Negatively, we may note :

1. That they cannot be the Godhead, or Divine in their nature, for (1) likeness of any kind was strictly forbidden (Deut. 4:15, 16, &c.); and (2) the Godhead is distinguished from them by being mentioned at the same time.
   
   
2. Though heavenly, or celestial and spiritual in their nature and character, they are distinguished from the angels (who, as their name implies, were spirits used as messengers).  Compare Rev. 5:8, 11 and 7:11, where, first the cherubim offer worship, and then the angels.  They must therefore be real spirit-beings, for they could hardly be represented emblematically and really in the same verse.  Moreover, they are never dismissed on errands as angels are, and are never seen apart from the Throne.
   
   
3. They cannot be merely symbols, for, though symbolic and emblematic representations of them were allowed to be made, they themselves are not symbolic, or we should have symbolic symbols of symbols, and no reality at all.
   
   
4. They cannot be a symbol of the "Church" or any portion of redeemed humanity, for they are distinguished from them in Rev. 5:9, 10, according to the best readings of the most ancient MSS. and critical Greek texts, where the "us" of v. 9 should be omitted, and the "us" and "we" of v. 10 should be "them" and "they."  Compare also Rev. 7:9-11.
   
   
5. For the same reason they cannot be symbols of "the four gospels" or books of any kind, for the cherubim are ministers associated with wrath; and call for the judgment plagues.  See Rev. 6 and 15:7.  Moreover, there is no connection between these and the presence of the cherubim in Eden, in the Tabernacle, in the Temple, and the Throne of God.

1. That the three root letters of kerub, = b, are the root letters of the word KaRaB, which reappear in our GRiP, GRaB, GRiPe, GRasP.  In a passive sense the notion would be that of holding something in safe keeping :  and, as a matter of fact, the symbolic representation of them were held fast to the mercy-seat, being made out of the same piece of gold (Ex. 25:18, 23).
   
   
2. In Gen. 3:24 they were placed to KEEP (or guard) the way to the tree of life, and preserve the hope of re-genesis for a ruined creation (cp. Gen. 2:15, where we have the word "keep" in this sense).
   
   
3. Their presence on the mercy-seat binds this hope with atonement, and with Israel.
   
   
4. On the vail the hope is bound up with the coming of the Christ in incarnation and redemption.
   
   
5. They are four in number, and four is the number of Creation (see. Ap. 10).
   
   
6. They are represented by the symbolic heads of the four great divisions of animate creation :  the lion (of wild beasts), the ox (of tame beasts), the eagle (of birds), man (of humanity).
   
   
7. They are beneath the Throne, for the earth is Jehovah's footstool.
   
   
8. Their song, when they speak, is of creation (Rev. 4:11), and is in connection with the earth.
   Redemption is a "new song" for them, relating to others.
   
   
9. We conclude therefore, that the cherubim are celestial or real spirit-beings, associated in some way with the embodiment of creation's hope as expressed in Rom. 8:19-23.  The emblematic representations made of them connect that hope with "the hope of Israel" and associate it with the blood-sprinkled mercy-seat, and the rent vail (Heb. 10:10,20.)